Charles Pigott on how the courts are applying the For Women Scotland ruling
- A county court judge has applied For Women Scotland in a dispute over the membership rules of a sporting association.
- This is believed to be the first judicial consideration of the ruling at any level in the context of a discrimination claim.
The reserved judgment in Haynes v Thomson on behalf of the English Blackball Pool Federation [2025] EWCC 50 was published on 1 August. It involved a claim for direct gender reassignment discrimination, brought by Ms Haynes. She is a trans woman and is described as an expert player of English eight-ball pool. She has a gender recognition certificate (GRC) under the Gender Recognition Act 2004.
The federation is an unincorporated association which organises pool competitions in England. In August 2023, it announced a change in its rules so that only people born female would be permitted to play in is female competitions and teams. That meant that Ms Haynes could
