header-logo header-logo

The last word on consent?

02 April 2015 / Charles Foster
Issue: 7647 / Categories: Features , Professional negligence
printer mail-detail
nlj_7647_charles-foster

Montgomery is the belated obituary, not the death knell, of medical paternalism, says Charles Foster

Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11, [2015] All ER (D) 113 (Mar) concerned a pregnant diabetic patient who was not warned by her consultant obstetrician about the risk that her baby, being large relative to the size of the mother’s pelvis, would have shoulder dystocia. The obstetrician thought that the mother would, if given the relevant statistics about the risk, opt for a Caesarean section. That, the obstetrician decided, would not be in the mother’s best interests: the mother would, in effect, make an objectively wrong decision about the risks of serious injury. By not providing the information, the obstetrician was protecting the patient against her own irrationality. The Supreme Court decided that, even though there were some obstetricians who would adopt that approach, the health board that employed the obstetrician was liable. The Bolam test had no place in the consideration of such cases. It adopted wholesale the decision of the High Court of

If you are not a subscriber, subscribe now to read this content
If you are already a subscriber sign in
...or Register for two weeks' free access to subscriber content

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Kingsley Napley—Claire Green

Kingsley Napley—Claire Green

Firm announces appointment of chief legal officer

Weightmans—Emma Eccles & Mark Woodall

Weightmans—Emma Eccles & Mark Woodall

Firm bolsters Manchester insurance practice with double partner appointment

Gilson Gray—Linda Pope

Gilson Gray—Linda Pope

Partner joins family law team inLondon

NEWS
The threat of section 21 ‘no fault’ eviction was banished this week, after the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 passed into law
The landmark Supreme Court’s decision in Johnson v FirstRand Bank Ltd—along with Rukhadze v Recovery Partners—redefine fiduciary duties in commercial fraud. Writing in NLJ this week, Mary Young of Kingsley Napley analyses the implications of the rulings
Barristers Ben Keith of 5 St Andrew’s Hill and Rhys Davies of Temple Garden Chambers use the arrest of Simon Leviev—the so-called Tinder Swindler—to explore the realities of Interpol red notices, in this week's NLJ
Mazur v Charles Russell Speechlys [2025] has upended assumptions about who may conduct litigation, warn Kevin Latham and Fraser Barnstaple of Kings Chambers in this week's NLJ. But is it as catastrophic as first feared?
Lord Sales has been appointed to become the Deputy President of the Supreme Court after Lord Hodge retires at the end of the year
back-to-top-scroll