header-logo header-logo

Sale of Old Master not negligent

28 June 2023
Issue: 8031 / Categories: Legal News , Commercial , Professional negligence
printer mail-detail
The Countess of Wemyss, Amanda Fielding has lost her appeal against an art dealer over a painting sold for £1.15m that later re-sold for £8m more

In Countess of Wemyss and March & Anor v Simon C Dickinson [2023] EWCA Civ 724, trustees of the Wemyss Heirlooms Trust had claimed breach of duty against the dealer, Simon C Dickinson, over the sale of Le Bénédicité, purportedly by 18th century artist Jean-Baptiste-Simeon Chardin. The painting, bought by the family in 1751, was sold as ‘Chardin and studio’ in 2014 after a light clean. The dealer thought it was not solely the work of the artist.

Six months later, however, the painting was re-sold for £9.3m after a deep clean revealed a Chardin signature, and a Chardin expert declared it solely the work of the artist.

The trustees’ claim was dismissed at the High Court after a seven-day trial, and on appeal to the Court of Appeal.

Delivering the judgment, Lady Justice Falk said: ‘There was no dispute that the sale that took place was in fact authorised.

‘…The pleaded particulars of negligence included, as one aspect, a failure to warn the trustees, but there was no suggestion that there was a contractual term that required the defendant to revert to the trustees prior to sale.’

Moreover, in relation to whether the leading expert on Chardin should have been consulted, Falk LJ said the judge found ‘the decision not to do so was not negligent, because doing so would be a “spin of the roulette wheel” that could destroy, rather than enhance, the value of the painting’.

Therefore, ‘in a counterfactual world where the defendant did consult the trustees prior to sale the advice would not have been negligent and the trustees would have followed that advice. It follows that the painting would still have been sold on the terms that it was.’

 

 

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Birketts—trainee cohort

Birketts—trainee cohort

Firm welcomes new cohort of 29 trainee solicitors for 2025

Keoghs—four appointments

Keoghs—four appointments

Four partner hires expand legal expertise in Scotland and Northern Ireland

Brabners—Ben Lamb

Brabners—Ben Lamb

Real estate team in Yorkshire welcomes new partner

NEWS
Robert Taylor of 360 Law Services warns in this week's NLJ that adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) risks entrenching disadvantage for SME law firms, unless tools are tailored to their needs
The Court of Protection has ruled in Macpherson v Sunderland City Council that capacity must be presumed unless clearly rebutted. In this week's NLJ, Sam Karim KC and Sophie Hurst of Kings Chambers dissect the judgment and set out practical guidance for advisers faced with issues relating to retrospective capacity and/or assessments without an examination
Delays and dysfunction continue to mount in the county court, as revealed in a scathing Justice Committee report and under discussion this week by NLJ columnist Professor Dominic Regan of City Law School. Bulk claims—especially from private parking firms—are overwhelming the system, with 8,000 cases filed weekly
Charles Pigott of Mills & Reeve charts the turbulent progress of the Employment Rights Bill through the House of Lords, in this week's NLJ
From oligarchs to cosmetic clinics, strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs) target journalists, activists and ordinary citizens with intimidating legal tactics. Writing in NLJ this week, Sadie Whittam of Lancaster University explores the weaponisation of litigation to silence critics
back-to-top-scroll