header-logo header-logo

Judicial pension appeal dismissed

01 February 2018
Issue: 7779 / Categories: Legal News , Profession
printer mail-detail
nlj_7779_news

Transitional provisions on judicial pensions not proportionate

Ministers unlawfully discriminated against more than 200 judges on grounds of age when it introduced transitional pension arrangements, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has held.

Dismissing the government’s appeal, in Ministry of Justice v McCloud, Mostyn & Ors Appeal No. UKEAT/0071/17/LA, Sir Alan Wilkie held that ministers failed to show the pension arrangements were a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

The previous judicial pension scheme closed in 2015. Only judges above a certain age were allowed to remain members of the historic scheme, and the rest of the serving judges were transferred to a new scheme that provides less valuable benefits.

Shubha Banerjee, solicitor at Leigh Day, who represents 230 judges, said: ‘Following the report of Lord Hutton in 2011 into ways of reducing the costs of public sector pensions, the government sought to make changes across the public sector including to the pensions of police, firefighters, teachers, prison officers and others.

‘For most public sector groups, changes to pension were made according to age—younger members of schemes were required to leave their very beneficial schemes and instead offered membership of less valuable schemes whilst older scheme members were allowed to remain in their very beneficial schemes. Changes were made to judicial pensions applying this distinction.’

The judges brought claims for direct discrimination and, as there were higher numbers of female and black and minority ethnic judges in the affected group, claims for indirect race and sex discrimination and equal pay.

Sir Alan said: ‘I have identified, in respect of the question of legitimate aims, a series of misdirections by the EJ (Employment Judge) by reason of his misunderstanding of and/or misapplication of the facts and the evidence. 

‘However, when the EJ considered the question of proportionate means, he did so on the assumption that the appellants had established legitimate aims. His approach to that issue was, in my judgment, correct in law and his decision, based on the largely undisputed evidence, cannot be faulted.’

An MoJ spokesperson said: ‘We recognise and value the important role of the judiciary. We are considering the court's findings and whether to pursue an appeal against this judgment.'

Issue: 7779 / Categories: Legal News , Profession
printer mail-details

MOVERS & SHAKERS

Birketts—trainee cohort

Birketts—trainee cohort

Firm welcomes new cohort of 29 trainee solicitors for 2025

Keoghs—four appointments

Keoghs—four appointments

Four partner hires expand legal expertise in Scotland and Northern Ireland

Brabners—Ben Lamb

Brabners—Ben Lamb

Real estate team in Yorkshire welcomes new partner

NEWS
Robert Taylor of 360 Law Services warns in this week's NLJ that adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) risks entrenching disadvantage for SME law firms, unless tools are tailored to their needs
From oligarchs to cosmetic clinics, strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPPs) target journalists, activists and ordinary citizens with intimidating legal tactics. Writing in NLJ this week, Sadie Whittam of Lancaster University explores the weaponisation of litigation to silence critics
Delays and dysfunction continue to mount in the county court, as revealed in a scathing Justice Committee report and under discussion this week by NLJ columnist Professor Dominic Regan of City Law School. Bulk claims—especially from private parking firms—are overwhelming the system, with 8,000 cases filed weekly
Writing in NLJ this week, Thomas Rothwell and Kavish Shah of Falcon Chambers unpack the surprise inclusion of a ban on upwards-only rent reviews in the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill
Charles Pigott of Mills & Reeve charts the turbulent progress of the Employment Rights Bill through the House of Lords, in this week's NLJ
back-to-top-scroll